Selection method
Require a recipe for the exact coffee
We included current US whole-bean coffees with an existing full Coffeedant review and a named roaster-published espresso dose and yield for the exact product. We selected three different first-shot decisions: a traditional chocolate-led coffee for milk, a darker espresso blend with a berry accent, and a light washed blend that can also move to filter. The recipe is the inclusion test, not evidence that a coffee is easier, tastes better or extracts consistently across machines. [1] [2] [3] [4]
We excluded generic espresso-labeled bags whose current page lacks a product-specific dose and yield. We also excluded single-origin lots whose recipe could disappear with the harvest and did not rank by a price we could not verify for the exact checkout selection. This is a short list of documented starting points, not a market-wide taste ranking.
The independent Analog account is from 2019. It shows one taster using a different ratio, which is useful evidence that a roaster recipe is not a final answer. The Geometry and Monarch owner reports illustrate preference and setup variation, without establishing a typical outcome for a new shipment. [5] [6] [7]
At a glance
Three published dose and yield pairs
| Exact coffee | Best first bag for | Roaster start | Skip if |
|---|---|---|---|
| Intelligentsia Coffee Black Cat Analog Espresso | A chocolate-led first shot for milk | 18 g in → 45 g out | You mainly want bright straight shots or a fixed named farm and variety. |
| Onyx Coffee Lab Monarch | A darker shot with winey berry beside chocolate | 19 g in → 47 g out | You want a lighter, tea-like fruit brief or need an unchanging lot. |
| Onyx Coffee Lab Geometry | A lighter washed-coffee experiment with filter fallback | 20 g in → 47 g out | You want a traditional low-brightness espresso or have no interest in filter as a backup use. |
First-bag choices
Use the recipe to learn a distinct coffee
A chocolate-led first shot for milk
Intelligentsia Coffee Black Cat Analog Espresso
Why: Intelligentsia gives the dose and beverage yield directly on the Analog product page. The darker Black Cat brief is a clear entry point if your household makes cappuccinos and wants a familiar chocolate direction.
Tradeoff: The page gives a target ratio but not a universal grinder setting for your basket or water. An older independent tasting used a different ratio; neither proves how a current bag tastes.
Skip if: You mainly want bright straight shots or a fixed named farm and variety.
Image: Intelligentsia Coffee. Intelligentsia official product package image, for identification; no Coffeedant brewing or tasting pictured.
Read the full review →
A darker shot with winey berry beside chocolate
Onyx Coffee Lab Monarch
Why: Onyx publishes a Monarch espresso guide with a 19 g dose, 47 g yield and a pressure timeline. The roaster designs this year-round blend specifically for espresso and describes a chocolate and winey-berry direction.
Tradeoff: Its Colombia and Ethiopia components are rotating lots. A published pressure profile cannot be reproduced exactly on every home machine, and individual owner reactions differ.
Skip if: You want a lighter, tea-like fruit brief or need an unchanging lot.
Image: Onyx Coffee Lab. Official Onyx product photograph used for identification; not a Coffeedant tasting photograph.
Read the full review →
A lighter washed-coffee experiment with filter fallback
Onyx Coffee Lab Geometry
Why: Onyx lists a separate 20 g to 47 g espresso recipe for Geometry and also publishes a filter method. The washed Colombia–Ethiopia blend gives a different first-bag question: whether you enjoy fruit and tea in a straight shot.
Tradeoff: A light roast may ask for more grinder adjustment than a familiar darker blend. One owner bought it for espresso and preferred it as pour-over; that is a preference signal, not a general result.
Skip if: You want a traditional low-brightness espresso or have no interest in filter as a backup use.
Image: Onyx Coffee Lab. Official Onyx Coffee Lab product image for identification. Packaging is not proof of current contents or a Coffeedant tasting photo.
Read the full review →A repeatable first shot
Record dose, beverage mass and taste
Match the bag and its roast date to the live roaster guide before starting. If your basket accepts the stated dose, weigh dry coffee and stop the shot near the published beverage mass. Record the time, grind setting, water and what you liked or disliked. Change one variable at a time. The ratio alone does not specify a universal grind size or temperature, and the Onyx pressure timelines assume equipment that can follow those profiles. [1] [4]
Analog’s 18 g to 45 g ratio and Monarch’s 19 g to 47 g ratio are close numerically, but that does not mean the beans should share a grinder setting or flavor expectation. Geometry’s 20 g to 47 g is a slightly shorter ratio, yet its lighter washed-coffee brief is a different sensory target. Treat each bag as a fresh dial-in. If your basket is smaller, scale within its documented capacity instead of forcing a dose that does not fit.
For milk, start with the coffee you want to notice after dilution. Analog’s darker chocolate brief and Monarch’s darker chocolate plus berry direction offer different reasons to try a small cappuccino. Geometry is more useful when you want to find out whether berry and tea survive a straight shot or whether you prefer it as filter. Those are inferences from roaster descriptions and owner context, not Coffeedant tasting. [1] [2] [3] [6]
Detailed comparison
What the recipe does and does not tell you
| Factor | Black Cat Analog Espresso | Monarch | Geometry |
|---|---|---|---|
| Dry dose | 18 g | 19 g | 20 g |
| Beverage yield | 45 g | 47 g | 47 g |
| Approximate ratio | 1:2.5 | about 1:2.47 | 1:2.35 |
| Roast brief | Darker than Black Cat Classic; Intelligentsia calls it traditional | Expressive dark, according to Onyx | Light, according to Onyx |
| Roaster notes | Dark chocolate, toasted marshmallow, baking spices | Dark chocolate, molasses, red wine, dried berries | Berries, stone fruit, Earl Grey, honeysuckle |
| Main uncertainty | Current lot and equipment adaptation | Rotating blend components and pressure control | Light-roast preference and dial-in |
Purchase and alternatives
Buy the first bag you can finish
Check exact whole-bean selection, current pack size, roast or shipping date, US stock, shipping and tax at checkout. A recipe cannot rescue an old bag or a grinder that cannot make useful espresso adjustments. Start with a manageable bag; keep it sealed in a cool, dry place and grind shortly before brewing. We make no current price, discount, cost-per-dose or value ranking.
If you want a fruit-led straight shot without making recipe availability the main filter, use our fruit-forward espresso guide. For a chocolate preference across different blends, see the chocolate-forward guide. If one bag must also serve drip, compare the dual-method picks. A separate espresso grinder remains part of the complete setup.
Coffeedant may earn from affiliate links elsewhere on this site at no extra cost to you. The roaster product photographs identify bags; they do not document Coffeedant brewing or tasting.
Evidence and limits
What our recommendation rests on
On November 11, 2026, we compared the current roaster product and brew pages with three existing full reviews, one older independent Analog tasting and individual owner reports. The best-for labels are editorial inferences from documented recipes and roaster flavor briefs. We did not buy coffee, taste these bags side by side, measure extraction, test freshness or establish owner failure rates. Roasters can change components and recipes; the delivered bag and current product page control the actual choice.
Quick answers
Espresso starting-recipe FAQ
Is 18 g to 45 g the right recipe for every espresso machine?
No. That is Intelligentsia’s Black Cat Analog starting point. Basket capacity, grind, water, roast age and taste can all change the useful dose or yield.
Does Onyx publish the same recipe for Monarch and Geometry?
No. The checked Onyx guide gives Monarch 19 g to 47 g and Geometry 20 g to 47 g, with different pressure timelines. Check the current guide for the bag you buy.
What if my machine cannot control pressure?
Use the published dose and yield as an initial reference, then adjust grind and taste on your machine. Do not treat Onyx’s pressure timeline as a requirement your equipment can meet.
Which bag also has a filter method?
Onyx publishes a filter recipe for Geometry. Monarch also has filter guidance, but this shortlist recommends Geometry specifically when a lighter washed-coffee filter fallback appeals to you.
Are the flavor notes Coffeedant tasting results?
No. They are the roasters’ descriptions. Coffeedant has not bought, brewed or tasted these bags or measured extraction.
How do I compare the cost of these recipes?
Check current bag size, price, shipping and roast date at the US seller, then divide the delivered bag cost by the number of doses you will actually use. This guide makes no current price or discount claim.
Attributable evidence
Sources checked November 11, 2026
- Intelligentsia Black Cat Analog US product ↗
Exact Analog identity, 18 g to 45 g espresso start, roast direction and roaster flavor notes. Checked November 11, 2026.
- Onyx Monarch US product ↗
Current blend identity, espresso intent, rotating lots and roaster flavor brief. Checked November 11, 2026.
- Onyx Geometry US product ↗
Current washed-blend identity, roast and roaster flavor brief. Checked November 11, 2026.
- Onyx espresso brew guides ↗
Monarch 19 g to 47 g and Geometry 20 g to 47 g starting recipes and pressure timelines. Checked November 11, 2026.
- Coffee Cantata Black Cat Analog review ↗
Independent 2019 tasting of one Analog bag; historical context only, not a current-lot guarantee. Checked November 11, 2026.
- Geometry owner discussion ↗
One buyer preferred filter after intending espresso; self-selected owner evidence. Checked November 11, 2026.
- Monarch owner discussion ↗
A setup-specific dial-in difficulty; anecdote, not a reliability or flavor rate. Checked November 11, 2026.
The first bag
A measured start is only the start
Try Analog when chocolate in milk is the target, Monarch when darker chocolate with winey berry appeals, or Geometry when you want a lighter washed-coffee experiment with a filter fallback. Each roaster supplies an actual starting recipe; your grinder, basket, water and taste decide the next adjustment.
Explore all bean reviews →